Skip to content

Brought to you by

Dentons logo

UK People Reward and Mobility Hub

The latest updates in employment, benefits, pensions and immigration

open menu close menu

UK People Reward and Mobility Hub

  • Home
  • Events
    • Past events
  • Who We Are
    • Meet the team
  • How we can help

Discrimination update – what constitutes a ‘philosophical belief’ under the Equality Act?

By Victoria Middleditch
January 9, 2020
  • Discrimination
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email Share on LinkedIn

An employee’s view that it is impossible for an individual to change their sex was held not to be a philosophical belief for the purposes of the Equality Act by an employment tribunal at a preliminary hearing.

Background

Ms Forstater worked as a consultant for the Center for Global Development (CGD), The CGD did not renew Ms Forstater’s contract and she claimed this was because of her ‘gender critical’ opinions. These were reflected in tweets where she posted that a person’s sex cannot be changed regardless of their stated gender identity. Her tweets canvassed her concerns with the proposed reforms to the Gender Recognition Act, stating that expanding the legal definition of women to include both males and females rendered the concept meaningless.

Ms Forstater contended that these views amounted to a philosophical belief within the meaning of the Equality Act 2010 (EqA) and the non-renewal of her contract was therefore a discriminatory act.

Ms Forstater’s claim was also on the basis that she was an applicant for employment and therefore protected under the EqA (as consultants don’t always have protection under the EqA). However, the judge did not decide on this point at the preliminary hearing. 

Analysis

The judge found Ms Forstater’s view met many of the required criteria for the definition of a philosophical belief protected by law. He determined that the belief was genuinely held and that the importance she attached to it proved it to be a belief rather than merely an opinion based on the present state of information. He also deemed this was a belief as to a weighty and substantial aspect of human life and behaviour and viewed the fact that her approach is largely supported by current law as evidence that the belief attained the necessary levels of cogency and cohesion.

However, Ms Forstater’s belief was crucially found to be incompatible with human dignity and the fundamental rights of others. This is a key requirement of a “philosophical belief” under the EqA.  Ms Forstater’s view denied the right of a person with a Gender Recognition Certificate to be the sex that they have transitioned to. The judge concluded that a core component of her belief was that she would refer to a person by the sex she considered appropriate even if that would violate their dignity and/or create a hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment. This approach was deemed not worthy of respect in a democratic society and so Ms Forstater’s belief failed to meet the definition of a philosophical belief.

The judge also addressed the implications his decision had for freedom of speech.  He stated that it was legitimate to exclude a belief that necessarily harms the rights of others.  By refusing to accept the full effect of a Gender Recognition Certificate, this belief caused harassment to trans women by insisting they are men and trans men by insisting they are women. The judge said that the human rights balancing act would not work in Ms Forstater’s favour because of her ‘absolutist’ approach.

What can we take from this?

This is a particularly interesting decision in light of the recent employment tribunal ruling that veganism is a philosophical belief. The crucial difference between the two cases is that veganism was not found to be incompatible with the rights of others.

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email Share on LinkedIn
Subscribe and stay updated
Receive our latest blog posts by email.
Stay in Touch
Victoria Middleditch

About Victoria Middleditch

Victoria is an employment lawyer in Dentons' London office. She provides support to businesses on the full range of employment law and human resources issues. Her experience includes advising on commercial transactions and re-organizations (including complex TUPE matters), employment disputes (both tribunal and civil court litigation), team moves, employment contracts and policies, bonus and commission schemes, and general day-to-day human resources issues.

All posts Full bio

You might also like...

  • Discrimination
  • Employee welfare
  • Family friendly rights
  • Legislative Changes

UK Employment Law Round-up – March 2018

In this issue we look at some of the key employment law developments that have been taking place over the […]

By Lauren Costello
  • ACAS
  • Disability
  • Discrimination
  • Employee welfare
  • Employment policies
  • Flexible working
  • Uncategorized

Acas publishes guidance on workplace neurodiversity

Acas has published guidance to help employers learn about neurodiversity and to suggest changes that can be made in the […]

By Victoria Middleditch
  • Compensation
  • Constructive dismissal
  • Discrimination
  • Government Proposals
  • Tribunal procedures

President of the Employment Tribunals announces increase in the Vento Bands

Following a recent consultation, the President of the Employment Tribunals has announced a rise in the compensation that employees can recover for 'injury to feelings', in the event that they suffer from discrimination in the workplace.

By Elizabeth Marshall

About Dentons

Dentons is the world’s largest law firm, delivering quality and value to clients around the globe. Dentons is a leader on the Acritas Global Elite Brand Index, a BTI Client Service 30 Award winner and recognized by prominent business and legal publications for its innovations in client service, including founding Nextlaw Labs and the Nextlaw Global Referral Network. Dentons’ polycentric approach and world-class talent challenge the status quo to advance client interests in the communities in which we live and work. www.dentons.com.

Dentons Largest Global Elite Law Firm

Twitter

Categories

Dentons logo

© 2021 Dentons

  • Legal notices
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of use
  • Cookies on this site